Hmmm, so many decisions...perhaps all of them? :) I'd definitely say yes to any of the Robert Newton films, and most likely Fairbanks over Power. And yes to The Princess Bride! Love that movie. But then there's Cuthroat Island, Blackbeard's Ghost if you want another spot of humor, and lots more (I found a great list of pirate movies here (http://www.geocities.com/captcutlass/Film.html).